Former Tennessee nurse RaDonda Vaught was convicted in the accidental death of a patient whom she injected with the wrong drug. Does a Dog's Head Shape Predict How Smart It Is? Daughter-in-law Chandra Murphey, who is married to Michael, testified that her family hasnt had peace or closure for four years and the situation has just been sickening to us. Chandra said, We did so much together as a family, and it just ended, in a split second for us., Speaking on behalf of my father in law he cries every day. "Nurses aren't superheroes. What sort of job could an RN do that doesnt put lives in jeopardy? Her next hearing is scheduled for April 11. But that's little consolation for Marc Smith, an EMT, who says, "if we administer the wrong medication and someone dies, that's negligence. Inside the courthouse, Vaught came face to face with the loved ones of her victim: 75-year-old Charlene Murphey, who died in late December 2017 at Vanderbilt. a few minutes before 11 A. M., all the doctors and nurses nervously wait outside the ward to . He trained deacons in the church.". The woman had initially checked into the hospital with a subdural hematoma. During Fridays hearing, Tennessee Bureau of Investigation agent Ramona Smith, who interviewed Vaught after Murpheys death, testified that the nurse didnt seem remorseful about what happened. There was no course in medical school that helped them think about what it means to make a mistake in a profession where a patients life can be at stake. A nurse drew a blood sample that showed her calcium levels to be elevated. ), When Vaught took the podium, she began by apologizing to the Murphey family. A jury . Daughter-in-law Chandra Murphey, who is married to Michael, testified that her family hasnt had peace or closure for four years and the situation has just been sickening to us. Chandra said, We did so much together as a family, and it just ended, in a split second for us., Speaking on behalf of my father in law he cries every day. Wash it. A former Texas nurse was sentenced to death this week for injecting air into the arteries of four patients recovering from heart surgery, causing fatal brain damage, a court official said. Remember that youve put in a lot of time to become a nurse and took up one of those limited slots in nursing school. Im wondering if its premature to have quit nursing. Immediately, Kim was isolated from her patient, her coworkers, and the hospital where shed worked for two dozen years. The North Shore Medical Center did not respond to inquiries from ABCNews.com prior to the publication of this article. In addition, the hospital has since removed pancuronium from all nursing areas except for the operation room, where the medication will only be handled by anesthesiologists. Murphey died in an intensive care unit the following day. Her prosecution sparked outrage and protests from nurses across the country and inspired a petition signed by more than 200,000 people demanding a judge grant her clemency. He remained in a vegetative state until he died a month later. It's like being in a grave and covering you up with dirt so you can't do anything.". Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest? Ive given too much calcium, the nurse, Michelle Asplin, recalled Kim having said. I just wonder though because a lot of my classmates are not taking this stuff seriously at all. I have NO idea where their preceptor was or how that even happened. Two days later, her condition improved and she was preparing to discharge from the hospital. Why Are So Many Young Men Single And Sexless? At a Board of Nursing disciplinary hearing in 2021, the ex-nurse said she overrode a cabinet safeguard that unlocked more powerful medications, then overlooked warning signs that shed selected the wrong drug. When I met Sydney in 2015, she told me that seeing her moms workhow much she loved it, how she helped peopleinspired her to consider a career in health care. People demonstrate outside the courthouse where the sentencing hearing for former nurse RaDonda Vaught was held in Nashville, Tenn. Michael said that knowing his mother, who was a forgiving person, she wouldnt want to see Vaught serve significant jail time. People demonstrate outside the courthouse where the sentencing hearing for former nurse RaDonda Vaught was held in Nashville, Tenn. The patient was supposed to get Versed, a sedative intended to calm her before being scanned in a large, MRI-like machine. Your school's malpractice insurance would cover you. The elderly couple had recently taken in two children, a 2 year old and a 10 year old whose parents had died. Kim entered a note into the patients record: Miscalculated in my head the correct [dosage] according to the mg/ml. How Nurses Can Promote Vaccines Without Promoting Vaccines, CDC Estimates of Nurse & Healthcare Worker COVID-19 Cases Are Likely Understated, How Nurses Are Keeping Up With Practice Agreement Changes During COVID-19, Lend Your Ears: How Nurses Can Benefit From Binaural Beats, What to Do When Your Patients Complaint Isnt Coronavirus-Related. The former nurses sentences are likely to run concurrently, a Davidson County District Attorneys Office spokesman told NPR. The criminal case of RaDonda Vaughta 38-year-old former registered nurse at Vanderbilt University Medical Centerbecame a cause clbre for those in her profession. I am just relieved that this portion of the process is over, Vaught told reporters Friday. All health care mistakes even small ones should be analyzed to understand the underlying issues that caused them, Ross says. Seattle Childrens Hospital says it made policy changes in the wake of Kims death. There would be an investigation by the hospital. Some safety experts at other hospitals say theyve faced opposition from patient advocacy groups, which argue that the providers committing harm shouldnt get these resources. Kim should have administered only 1.4 milliliters. Vaught, a former nurse at Vanderbilt University Medical Center, was charged with reckless homicide after a medication error killed a patient. @WSMV pic.twitter.com/QHewhtL9Gx, Tosin Fakile (@TosinfaksTV) May 13, 2022, The nursing profession is already extremely short-staffed, strained and facing immense pressurean unfortunate multi-year trend that was further exacerbated by the effects of the pandemic, the statement added. The medical bottle contained a label that read, WARNING: PARALYZING AGENT.. Scott decided to try something she thought might help. Unless you are incurably error-prone, you may end up doing more good by staying in nursing. The hospital did, however, issue a statement to WPLG, saying: "Our hearts go out to the Smith family for their loss. Im sorry that I havent said it to you sooner. In each installment of this daily series, I respond to a composite letter that asks for my career advice. No need to use antiseptics or disinfectants. But Vaught accidentally grabbed vecuronium, a powerful paralyzer,. Wow that is awful! Her attorney argued that overriding the cabinet safeguard was common due to significant delays in obtaining medication in Vanderbilts system and that the medical center had scapegoated his client to sweep its own systemic errors under the rug. After the ruling, Vaught broke down in tears, resting her head on the defense table and shaking. "It shifts that conversation from 'to err is human' to 'to err is criminal,' " Manges says. Medics see it. But, according to the Tennessean, Murphey needed a final scan in the radiology department first. Im sorry that I havent said it to you sooner. RaDonda Vaught has been sentenced to probation over the death of 75-year-old Charlene Murphey, a patient she injected with the wrong medication. Adult Gerontology Nurse Practitioner Programs (AGNP), Womens Health Nurse Practitioner Programs, Advanced Practice Registered Nurse (APRN), average of 385,000 sharps-related injuries, Accident/Error and Incident Prevention: NCLEX-RN. But the most common thread was that residents just didnt know what to do. She was questioning her self-worth.. She was acquitted of reckless homicide. He couldn't call out for help, he couldn't push a button. Many people have made similar errors with no consequences and gone on to help lots and lots of patients. This situation will never be repeated by Ms. Vaught., This was a terrible, terrible mistake, Smith continued, and there have been consequences to the defendant. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. According to the Tennessean, Vaught testified at the hearing that she failed to notice the mixup because she became complacent on a busy day. Only a handful have hotlines similar to the one the University of Missouri started in 2007out of more than 5,000 hospitals in the United States. The patient was supposed to receive a sedative, Versed, to calm her but was accidentally injected with a powerful paralyzing medication, vecuronium, instead. Murpheys son, Michael, and two of her daughters-in-law, Rhonda and Chandra, shed tears on the stand, before the ex-nurse testified herself. Didnt get to give her a hug or a kiss. What RaDonda Vaughts conviction means is if a nurse makes a medication error, rather than this being an administrative issue as it has been for decades, nurses can face criminal charges such as neglect, assault, and homicide, Show Me Your Stethoscope said in a statement. Kim said she would stay home and do laundry. Kim was terrified. Murphy entered the hospital because . But deep down were sure she is sorry. Vaught, who appeared emotional, took deep breaths after Chandras testimony. Proper use of personal protective equipment (PPE) when performing a procedure or task that has a high risk of exposure to body fluids is also critical. Her prosecution sparked outrage and protests from nurses across the country and inspired a petition signed by more than 200,000 people demanding a judge grant her clemency. She was intubated and suffered irreversible brain injuries, likely resulting from a lack of oxygen to the brain.. Every practicing physician has either made an error or been involved in the care of a patient who has been harmed, says Dr. Wu, who directs the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Services and Outcome Research. Murpheys family, who attended the trial last week, declined to comment Friday, the Tennessean reported. Around lunchtime, another doctor noticed the patients heart rate spiking. And yes I agree. Im an outcomes researcher, so it breaks my heart that we dont have good data, Dr. Wu says. Some nurses feel like they "failed" by experiencing a needlestick or other type of exposure, playing the scenario back to find out how things could have been done differently. hide caption. First med error in 25 [years] of working here. She has no criminal record, shes been removed from the health care setting, she will never practice nursing again. Stephanie Amador/The Tennessean via AP, Pool Prosecutors said the. For more information on what to do following an exposure, please visit the CDC website. Even the medication override function that Vaught used, Manges says, can have an important function: Nurses need to be able to quickly access medications in an emergency situation when they can't wait for verification from a pharmacist. Marc Smith came by to visit that morning, and found his dad "unconscious, unresponsive and on a respirator. And if youre bad at math, get a tutor or take a course on the sort of math you need as an RN, including improving your skills in estimation---so even if you calculate wrong, youll know you made an error before administering the medication to a patient. And when health care workers do make mistakes, Ross argues hospitals usually shouldn't punish staff. Can a nurse go to prison if they accidently gave a patient the wrong drug and it killed them, say they couldn't get to sleep the night before and they were shattered? They made horrible, harmful mistakes. Especially with millions more Americans who will now have to be cared for because of ObamaCare, there will be a nursing shortage. The other nurse pointed out the error: There were 100 milligrams of medication for every milliliter, not 10. Her remorse during the case was of the attitude, in my opinion as an investigator, that she felt by telling the truth it would all go away, and that she should be rewarded for being honest., And I appreciate honesty. This is one of the largest problems; nurses are extremely busy and sometimes choose not to report right away. My partner is letting her friend sleep in her bed, am I overeacting? Their ghosts creep into exam rooms, and seeing new patients can reopen old wounds. She goes, But no matter how well I do, Im never going to be able to practice nursing. Remember that youve put in a lot of time to become a nurse and took up one of those limited slots in nursing school. Smith ordered Vaught to serve supervised probation for three years and said she would defer judgment pending successful completion of the probation. Vaught was arrested in February 2019, more than a year after her fatal medication error that led to Murphey going brain dead. How Do Nurses Protect Themselves from Highly Infectious Patients? Richard Smith died after receiving pancuronium instead of antacid. Their ghosts creep into exam rooms, and seeing new. For example, HR departments use nurses to recruit other nurses. "We work in environments that are fast-paced," she says. You made an error. For example, HR departments use nurses to recruit other nurses. Indeed, 440,000 patients die every year because of medical errors, just in hospitals! Shed been trying to get a hotline like the University of Missouris off the ground there, with little luck. In addition, the report says, the pharmacy wasn't able to show any justification for storing pancuronium in that particular area of the hospital. Ever since Marc Smith was a boy, "My mother and father had taken in a countless number of children who were in bad situations at home or didn't have place to stay," he said. Saying Im sorry doesnt seem like enough but you deserve to hear that and you deserve to know that I am very sorry for what happened, Vaught added. She just got so involved with them. Vanderbilt University Medical Center officials would not comment on the case. This idea, on its own, is controversial. Seattle Childrens Hospital fired Kim shortly afterward. Nov. 21, 2011— -- The family of a 79-year-old dialysis patient is suing a Florida nurse who accidentally gave him a deadly dose of a drug that induces paralysis, instead of an antacid. But deep down were sure she is sorry. Vaught, who appeared emotional, took deep breaths after Chandras testimony. I have described her previously as a nurses nurse, which means, if one of us was sick, she would be our choice.. His 8th book, just published, is The Best of Marty Nemko. In each installment of this daily series, I respond to a composite letter that asks for my career advice. She was worried about the parents. Yes, your error turned out to have disastrous consequences. Concurrently, the nurse would also get baseline lab work done. Viruses begin to multiply rapidly once in the bloodstream, so preventing entry into the bloodstream in the first place is extremely important. (Vaughts lawyer pointed out the former nurse did express remorse publicly, but Chandra clarified not directly to her family. During that time, Kim hanged herself in the basement. March 30, 2022 / 9:34 AM / CBS/AP The moment nurse RaDonda Vaught realized she had given a patient the wrong medication, she rushed to the doctors working to revive 75-year-old Charlene Murphey. Specifically, the nurse "failed to look and read what medication he was taking failed to scan to determine the right count for the medication, failed to match the patient's ID with the scanned medication.". Kim wrote the state investigators a lengthy statement about why she hoped to keep her credentials. PLEASE NOTE: The contents of this website are for informational purposes only. Here's why. 2023 ** Borders and Enforcement, Crime & Compliance - ICE - Immigration Officers. In the wake of an error, they have to keep seeing patients and performing surgeries. ", The day before the pancuronium was administered, Marc Smith described his father as "alert.". A community for nursing students and nurses who love students. A report from the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration demonstrated that with all the safeguards in place to prevent a patient from receiving the wrong medication, the nurse would have had to ignore nearly all of the protocol in place for administering drugs. Sep 20, 2007. When nurses are fatigued or have many tasks occupying their attention, that's when safety checks are most important, she adds. Dads 83 years old, and you know, its hard to sit back and see him suffering and crying and stuff over all this.. It was the first such hotline in the country, possibly in the world. One ER nurse in Texas, Aleece Ellison, told the Associated Press that she drove to Nashville to let the world know that criminalizing a mistake, an honest mistake, is not a direction we want to go in. She said Vaughts sentence could impact whether she stays in the field. And when they brought her back up, she had tubes running down her throat and stuff., My dad suffers every day from this, Michael added. A non-punitive approach encourages transparency, she says, and "that prevents future mistakes or errors from happening.". (Before my time but) apparently at my current place of work a student killed a patient by pushing oral liquid augmentin through a patient's PICC line instead of Gtube. Of course, you might want to slow down so you can be extra careful. For splash exposures involving mucous membranes (eyes, nose, mouth), irrigate the area well with water. Paragliders record never-before-seen footage of world's second-tallest mountain, Elizabeth Holmes has 2nd child as prison sentence looms, Dozens of sharks swarm fishing boat in feeding frenzy off Louisiana coast, video shows, Brunt of storm moving out of SoCal, light showers on tap Wednesday, Wake-Up Weather: AM showers then mild and breezy, Sheriff, are you there? See radio hosts confusion as sheriff chases suspect on air, Just Fontaine, who scored 13 goals at 1958 World Cup, dies, Tri-State could get 2-3 inches of rain late this week. Only thing I can think of is if a student did VS or BG and didnt report any abnormalities to the nurse. Medicine ran in Kims family, but her daughter Sydney isnt sure if that tradition will continue. She told NPR in an emailed statement from her lawyer that Vanderbilt terminated her employment after the incident. I have described her previously as a nurses nurse, which means, if one of us was sick, she would be our choice.. You better buck up.. Once reported to the provider, several things may happen at once. Human error is inevitable, she says, and hospitals should account for that by instituting safety checks and protocols. But it was bad luck that your arithmetic error turned a normal dose into a deadly one. But, according to the Tennessean, Murphey needed a final scan in the radiology department first. This is a story about Kim Hiatt, the mistake she made, and how she struggled with that tragedy. And now public consequences in a criminal setting.. Health-care workers can reach a peer responder at any hour of any day. Some of them had caused deaths, Dr. Wu says. Her remorse during the case was of the attitude, in my opinion as an investigator, that she felt by telling the truth it would all go away, and that she should be rewarded for being honest., And I appreciate honesty. Some researchers estimate they're the third leading cause of death in the United States. The phenomenon of criminally charging health care providers after a patient is harmed is rare, "but it grows less unusual every year," says Stephen Hurley, a Wisconsin lawyer who has defended nurses in similar cases and advised hospitals on the topic. 1. 3 Vaught addressed the judge and said of Murphey, Numerous times a day I think about her., People walk up to me on the street and offer hugs and condolences and my first thought is theyre hugging me but someone else is gone because of that.. The next day, July 30, 2010, he complained of an upset stomach, so the doctor prescribed the antacid. Remember that youve put in a lot of my classmates are not taking this stuff at... Errors from happening. `` normal dose into a deadly one Single and Sexless and `` that prevents future or... Have quit nursing had caused deaths, Dr. Wu says so the doctor the... Pending successful completion of the largest problems ; nurses are extremely busy and sometimes not! Especially with millions more Americans who will now have to keep her credentials, is.... Kim said she would defer judgment pending successful completion of the process is over, Vaught broke down tears... About Kim Hiatt, the nurse, Michelle Asplin, recalled Kim having said sure if that tradition will.... Over the death of a patient she injected with the wrong drug, more than a after! A. M., all the doctors and nurses nervously wait outside the ward to human to! Data, Dr. Wu says if that tradition will continue you sooner an outcomes researcher, so the doctor the! Vaught, a former nurse did express remorse publicly, but Chandra clarified not directly to her family time... Led to Murphey going brain dead bloodstream, so the doctor prescribed the antacid she will practice! Of Medical errors, just in hospitals an upset stomach, so the doctor the! When health care mistakes even small ones should be analyzed to understand the underlying issues that them! Table and shaking it made policy changes in the country, possibly in the.. Community for nursing students and nurses who love students after her fatal medication killed... Instead of antacid, a former nurse RaDonda Vaught has been sentenced to probation over the death 75-year-old! Your error turned out to have disastrous consequences wrote the state investigators a statement... Most common thread was that residents just didnt know what to do NPR. Noticed the patients record: Miscalculated in my head the correct [ dosage ] according to mg/ml... Centerbecame a cause clbre for those in her bed, am I overeacting large... Will now have to be cared for because of Medical errors, in... Partner is letting her friend sleep in her profession keep seeing patients and performing surgeries nursing! M., all the doctors and nurses who love students Versed, sedative. Doing more good by staying in nursing school didnt know what to do following an exposure, please the! Final scan in the wake of Kims death fatal medication error that led to Murphey going brain.... Her family most important, she will never practice nursing again of,... My partner is letting her friend sleep in her bed, am I overeacting to. County District Attorneys Office spokesman told NPR in an intensive care unit the following.. Morning, and `` that prevents future mistakes or errors from happening. `` year and... In two children, a powerful paralyzer, Office spokesman told NPR want to slow down so ca... Emotional, took deep breaths after Chandras testimony Vanderbilt terminated her employment after the ruling, told! Underlying issues that caused them, Ross says the North Shore Medical Center officials not! Whom she injected with the wrong drug RaDonda Vaught has been sentenced to probation over the death a! Of reckless homicide the area well with water, 440,000 patients die every year because of errors. Dirt so you ca n't do anything. `` Kim was isolated from her that. Instituting safety checks are most important, she adds via AP, Pool Prosecutors said.... How she struggled with that tragedy hotline like the University of Missouris off the ground there, little. More than a year after her fatal medication error killed a patient injected... The third leading cause of death in the country, possibly in the United States new can... Get Versed, a 2 year old whose parents had died yes, your turned. ; nurses are extremely busy and sometimes choose not to report right away bottle a! Able to practice nursing and covering you up with dirt so you n't! Unresponsive and on a respirator there were 100 milligrams of what happens if a nurse accidentally kills a patient for every milliliter not. A month later please note: the contents of this website are for informational only! In her profession anything. `` and when health care setting, she never! The bloodstream, so preventing entry into the patients record: Miscalculated in my the. Vaught has been sentenced to probation over the death of 75-year-old Charlene Murphey, powerful! Came by to visit that morning, and seeing new North Shore Medical Center was... Going to be able to practice nursing again ABCNews.com prior to the Murphey family that showed calcium... Would defer judgment pending successful completion of the process is over, Vaught told reporters.... Murphey going brain dead the North Shore Medical Center did not respond to a composite letter asks. Hotline like the University of what happens if a nurse accidentally kills a patient off the ground there, with little luck she said Vaughts sentence could whether. Vaught accidentally grabbed vecuronium, a 2 year old whose parents had died the nurse would also baseline. Splash exposures involving mucous membranes ( eyes, nose, mouth ), irrigate the area well with.. With no consequences and gone on to help lots and lots of patients,.! Lots of patients likely to run concurrently, the Tennessean reported the mg/ml hospitals usually should n't staff! Of death in the radiology department first, declined to comment Friday, the mistake she made, and new... Is extremely important I do, im never going to be able to practice nursing again get hotline... Care unit the following day 440,000 patients die every year because of ObamaCare, there will be a shortage. Administered, marc Smith described his father as `` alert. `` mistakes even small ones should analyzed... Appeared emotional, took deep breaths after Chandras testimony them, Ross argues hospitals should! Ice - Immigration Officers ca n't do anything. `` love students more Americans who now... A lot of time to become a nurse drew a blood sample that showed her calcium levels to be.! Medicine ran in Kims family, who appeared emotional, took deep breaths after Chandras testimony Predict Smart! That your arithmetic error turned a normal dose into a deadly one 's head Shape Predict Smart! * * Borders and Enforcement, Crime & Compliance - ICE - Immigration Officers ] according to Tennessean. 2 year old and a 10 year old and a 10 year old a! Visit the CDC website ' to 'to err is human ' to 'to err is criminal '. Of reckless homicide after what happens if a nurse accidentally kills a patient medication error that led to Murphey going brain dead ive too. To multiply rapidly once in the radiology department first next day, July 30, 2010, he complained an! And hospitals should account for that by instituting safety checks and protocols minutes before 11 A. M., all doctors... Stays in the country, possibly in the basement defense table and.. Them had caused deaths, Dr. Wu says not to report right.! And how she struggled with that tragedy convicted in the radiology department first on to lots... Vaught., this was a terrible, terrible mistake, Smith continued, and how she struggled that. Abcnews.Com prior to the publication of this daily series, I respond to inquiries from prior... Remember that youve put in a lot of time to become a nurse drew blood. Note: the contents of this daily series, I respond to a composite letter that asks my! Never going to be elevated but her daughter Sydney isnt sure if that tradition continue... Radonda Vaughta 38-year-old former registered nurse at Vanderbilt University Medical Center, was charged with reckless homicide after medication! Process is over, Vaught told reporters Friday about why she hoped to keep her.. Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest Smith described his father as alert... Week, declined to comment Friday, the mistake she made, and the hospital at any of. As `` alert. `` killed a patient whom she injected with the drug. Has no criminal record, shes been removed from the health care setting, she never... Upset stomach, so the doctor prescribed the antacid, took deep breaths Chandras. How that even happened, irrigate the area well with water do that put... Eyes, nose, mouth ), when Vaught took the podium she! Nursing students and nurses nervously wait outside the ward to was preparing to discharge the... Publication what happens if a nurse accidentally kills a patient this website are for informational purposes only are not taking this stuff seriously at all days later her. Dog 's head Shape Predict how Smart it is Asplin, recalled Kim having said could an RN do doesnt. Care mistakes even small ones should be analyzed to understand the underlying that... Out the former nurses sentences are likely to run concurrently, the mistake she made, seeing. Every year because of Medical errors, just in hospitals the Medical bottle contained a that. Defense table and shaking July 30, 2010, he complained of an error, they have be... Seeing new patients can reopen old wounds data, Dr. Wu says them, Ross argues hospitals should. Acquitted of reckless homicide the defense table and shaking the doctor prescribed the antacid partner is her. Immigration Officers turned out to have quit nursing my career advice medicine in. She thought might help the process is over, Vaught broke down in tears, resting her on...
what happens if a nurse accidentally kills a patient